Alex Coal hosts a hotline on Lil Sis, discussing the growing intimacy between Lucky Fae and his new stepsister, Haley Spades. They had started making out and getting hot on movie dates. Haley revealed that their parents left them unexpectedly, and Lucky got her pants off to lick and finger bang her. Haley provided a blowout, making the two eager to hook up. Alex ends the call, stating that they have a normal connection and shouldn't let labels stop them.
Jessica Ryan reads spells while her step-aunt, Alex Jett, inquires about a celebration. Jessica's new stepdaughter, Kenzie Reeves, shows off her costume and finds out her mother has changed her mind about going. Alex, who is a virgin, confesses to getting some tonight. Jessica startsles him and swallows his penis, revealing his hardon. The girls part ways, and they move into Alex's bedroom, where they discover Haley Spades waiting for him. Haley notices the pleasure of having two more girls involved, and she tries to suck from Kenzie. Jessica straddles Kenzie's face and lowers herself to consume her. When it's Jessica's turn, she lets Alex take her on her back, while Haley and Kenzie go for it in a lesbian 69 behind her.
Britt Blair and Haley Spades are baking Thanksgiving pies while Tyler Cruise, Britt's stepbrother, creates crafts and takes sly looks at the girls' miniskirts. They discuss their stepfathers' sexual orientation and Haley's desire to fuck Britt's stepfather. Tyler witnesses the girls mocking his crafts and tries to fuck him. Britt plays a practical joke on him, lifting her miniskirt and slamming her in the dog. Haley masturbates while watching her friend get fucked by Tyler. Tyler continues to fuck Britt in reverse cowgirl, and the females give Tyler a double facial of sperm.
Haley Spades celebrates Valentine's Day with her crush on her professor, giving him gifts like chocolates, flowers, and her moist college pussy.
Haley Spades and her stepbrother Jodie Johson are working on their homework, but Haley wonders if she's bored enough to screw Jodie. She confronts Jodie, who needs help, and later, in her bedroom, she wears a ripped one-piece garment to fuck Jodie. Haley is gentle and loving, revealing her tits and riding in reverse cowgirl fashion. She hopes to be knocked up by Jodie, but grinds down to get a nice creampie of cum.
Ava Sinclaire, Haley Spades, and Paris White play together while studying, accidentally forgetting to ask for study assistance from the teaching assistant. They learn anatomy together.
Isiah Maxwell and Haley Spades engage in intense makeout, with Isiah eating out of Haley's pussy and Haley giving him a deep kiss. Isiah plows through Haley, beaming throughout.
Haley Spades enters Codey Steele's bedroom to smell his laundry, but is initially scared. Later, Haley is in her tank top and thong on the couch when Codey enters. Haley believes Codey is interested in her, but he easily slides into her. To overcome their differences, Haley uses doggie tricks to give Codey serious fuck. She clings to Haley's voluptuous form and sucks her goo from his balls and cock. Codey complies with Haley's request to cum by showing up late and providing her with a generous load.
Haley Spades creates a chart to determine the ideal size of dicks, and her friend Jazmin Luv helps her with this task. Juan Loco, Haley's stepbrother, enters and they discuss the project. Haley doesn't encounter any dicks in the six-to-seven-inch range, but they agree to measure Juan's penis. Haley apologizes for not giving him a hug immediately, and Jazmin tries to criticize her decisions. Haley and Jazmin make a joint BJ, and they ride Juan's dick in cowgirl fashion. Juan gives Haley another chance, but Haley gets on her hands and knees, almost sending Juan into a cumming situation. Just in time, he smashes a nut all over Haley's behind, providing Jazmin with a tasty surprise.
Haley Spades is tricked by her swap parents, Bunny Madison and Charles Dera, into believing Charles will use his super sperm to conceive Bunny and Haley. Haley is prepared for conception and displays her body on the kitchen table. Charles is seduced by Haley and throat-fucks her. Bunny and Juan Loco investigate, but Bunny is determined to get his switch mommy to screw him over. Juan and Haley share a real family exchange, with Charles riding Bunny like a backwards cowgirl and Juan riding Haley.
Haley Spades and her friends Madi Collins and Nadia Noja are excited for golf season and set up a putt-putt course to practice their strokes. They engage in various activities, including teasing and fucking each other. Haley questions Nathan's ability to be like his stepbrothers, who constantly put their ass through hardships. Nathan discovers Haley with the putting green pressed up to her vagina, defining her lips with the outline of the hole. Madi and Nadia get into a line of lust, with Madi eating out Haley and Nadia taking a reverse cowgirl stiffie ride. Nathan rewards the girls with a triple BJ, but Haley wants him to cum on her ass.